Roof Overlay vs Tear-Off
An overlay (also called a roof-over or re-roof) puts new shingles on top of the old ones. A tear-off strips the roof down to the wood deck first. Here's how they compare.
How much does an overlay save?
The saving is mostly the tear-off and disposal you skip, about $1–$3 per sq ft. The Journal of Light Construction notes that a typical 20-square reroof costs at least $1,000 less than a tear-off, and some contractors put overlays at about 25% cheaper overall.
| Overlay | Tear-off | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Lower | Higher |
| Time on the job | Shorter | Longer |
| Deck inspected and repaired | No | Yes |
| Weight on the structure | Two layers | One layer |
| Ice-and-water shield, new flashing | Limited | Full |
| Manufacturer warranty | Often reduced | Full |
When an overlay isn't allowed
Building codes in most US areas follow the International Residential Code, which doesn't allow a new layer over a roof that already has two layers, or over shingles that are water-soaked or badly deteriorated. Check with your local building department.
When an overlay can make sense
- There's only one existing layer, lying flat, with no leaks.
- The deck feels solid when walked on.
- You plan to sell soon and need a sound roof at the lowest cost.
When to choose a tear-off
- Leaks, soft spots or sagging, which point to deck damage you need to see.
- Curled or buckled shingles that won't give a flat base.
- You plan to stay for many years and want the full warranty.
Compare both options with real numbers: run the calculator with and without tear-off.
More roof cost guides
- Roof cost calculator
- By material
- Per square
- Measure a roof
- By house size
- Tear-off cost
- Decking cost
- Metal vs shingles
- How long it takes
Frequently asked questions
Is it OK to put new shingles over old shingles?
It's allowed in many areas when there's only one existing layer in good condition, but it hides the deck and usually shortens the new roof's life. Most roofers recommend a tear-off when you can afford it.
How many layers of shingles are allowed?
Most US codes allow a maximum of two layers. If you already have two, the old roofing must be removed.
Does an overlay void the shingle warranty?
Not always, but many manufacturers offer weaker coverage for overlays. Ask for the warranty terms in writing.